?

Log in

 
 
04 April 2009 @ 05:07 pm
voting challenge three  
Hey guys, I'm so sorry that this is late but I've been bedridden with the flu for the last week. Voting will stay up for the next couple of days and then we will start challenge 3 on time.

SKIPPING: hermionesparkle houseforlife quiddity_ allllure ralphy137 stam_fan17

VOTING RULES
- Don't vote for or against yourself, or ask other people to vote for or against you.
- IF YOU ENTERED, YOU SHOULD VOTE.
- Pleasure use the form when you submit your votes.
- All submitted icons should remain anonymous until the results have been posted.
- Make sure that the reasons that you vote for icons are purely based on the icon itself, not things like 'I don't like BW icons...' or anything along those lines.

Voting will be closed on Sunday, results will be posted on Monday as well as a new challenge.

The form:



01. 02. 03. 04.
05. 06. 07.



ALL COMMENTS will be SCREENED until voting closes.
 
 
 
Janine.allllure on April 4th, 2009 06:14 am (UTC)
LEAST FAVORITE ICONS
#01 - it's just way too blue looking.
#05 - the crop is too close, making it look blurry and the coloring is too dark.
#06 - it seems to be tinted a weird color, and parts of it are over sharpened but other parts are extremely blurry.

FAVORITE ICONS
#07 - the crop is magnificent.
#03 - the texture and the text just fit perfectly!
Mary: kate thank youelectrical_s on April 4th, 2009 06:21 am (UTC)
LEAST FAVORITE ICONS
##5 - too dark
##1 - bad colouring. it's too cyanish.
##4 - text don't fit the icon

FAVORITE ICONS
##7 - I like this border and colouring is great
##2 - nice cropping
Heather: anistonsetentpet on April 4th, 2009 01:20 pm (UTC)
LEAST FAVORITE ICONS
#1 - the coloring is a little off, her skin is a bit blue.
#5 - the icon is a bit too dark. brightening up the colors would have made it stand out a bit more.
#4 - the icon is a bit pixilated especially in the blue cape area.

FAVORITE ICONS
#7 - the coloring and crop are nicely done.
#2 - the crop and contrast are nice.
(Deleted comment)
Becca: Doctor Who || Rose | Doctor | Ninequiddity_ on April 4th, 2009 05:20 pm (UTC)
LEAST FAVORITE ICONS
01 - the blue coloring is very unnatural. cropping is too plain and doesn't graby your attention
05 - lacks contrast. too dark.
06 - cropping is dull. coloring falls flat.

FAVORITE ICONS
02 - fantastic use of negative space.
07 - great coloring and border.
Allison: monkey [katy perry]vapor on April 4th, 2009 05:32 pm (UTC)
LEAST FAVORITE ICONS
03 -- text is hard to read and Kate needs contrast
05 -- too dark
06 -- dull crop and the b&w is off

FAVORITE ICONS
02 -- great crop
07 -- very pretty composition
Clara: house: joyhouseforlife on April 5th, 2009 02:11 am (UTC)
LEAST FAVORITE ICONS
5- too dark
1- too much blue, overall iocn is a bit too dark
2- over sharpened, too much black dominating the icon

FAVORITE ICONS
7- clever idea, nice colouring
4- nice colouring and good use of text